The Rise and Fall of Miss Fannie’s Biscuits

Step into the heartwarming world of Amish life with The Rise and Fall of Miss Fannie’s Biscuits – The Musical at the Blue Gate Music Hall, running July 1 through October 25, 2025.

In this mystery-comedy musical, Fannie Miller, an unlikely but determined baking contest finalist, finds herself in a sticky situation as fellow contestants vanish one by one. Enter Foster Bates, a retired cop turned amateur detective—together, they’ll whisk you through cake clues, quirky suspects, and quiet reveals that charm and delight in equal measure.

Perfect for families, faith-based communities, and anyone craving a blend of whimsy, suspense, and heart, this show brings Amish country warmth to life with engaging characters, cozy humor, and a playful whodunit twist. Expect toe-tapping tunes, wholesome laughter, and enough heart to satisfy both mystery lovers and those who appreciate a good bake-off.

Don’t miss this opportunity to immerse yourself in a delightful mystery-filled escape nestled in Northern Indiana—where friendship, faith, and fun collide in every scene.